Western & Central Suffolk County, NY

What is your home actually worth?

Not an algorithm's guess pulled from public records. A realistic price range from Edana Kiernan and Thomas Brady at Vintage American Realty — local real estate brokers who review your home personally, with the comparable sales behind it.

No obligation, no bots. Edana or Tom reviews your home personally and replies within one business day.

Owner & Broker Edana Kiernan

Firm Vintage American Realty, Oakdale NY

Associate Broker Thomas Brady

The Difference

An algorithm has never walked your street.

Automated estimates can be useful as a starting point, but they can't always account accurately for the things that make one Suffolk County home different from another — condition, improvements, location, lot characteristics, flood considerations and other property-specific factors. A manual valuation lets us look at those differences alongside relevant comparable sales.

Automated Estimate

$—,000

Generated instantly from public records

Comparable selection may not reflect the homes we would consider most relevant
Condition, updates and layout may not be captured accurately
Property-specific factors can be difficult for an automated model to interpret
No one to call with questions

Manual Valuation

Prepared by hand

Reviewed personally by Edana or Tom, typically within 1 business day

Relevant local comparables from western & central Suffolk
Adjusted for your home's actual condition and updates
Accounts for zoning, flood maps, and street-level factors
A direct line to a licensed broker to ask questions

How It Works

Three steps. One conversation.

Send your address

Submit your address above — takes about ten seconds. No account, no obligation to list.

We review it by hand

Edana or Tom pulls relevant comparables from western and central Suffolk, weighs condition and recent local sales, and works out your range personally.

You get a real range

A written price range with the comparable sales behind it, delivered within one business day. If you want a firm number, that takes a walk-through — and we will explain what a visit can clarify.

Meet Your Local Brokers

A family brokerage. A personal connection.

Edana Kiernan and her father, Thomas Brady, help homeowners across western and central Suffolk County make informed real estate decisions.

Edana Kiernan, owner and broker of Vintage American Realty

Edana KiernanOwner & Licensed Real Estate Broker

Owner & Licensed Real Estate Broker

Edana Kiernan

Edana founded Vintage American Realty in 2021 with a clear goal: make real estate feel more welcoming, personal, and approachable for clients and agents alike.

As owner and broker, she leads a boutique firm that pairs a family atmosphere with modern tools. Her approach centers on honest guidance, clear information, and helping clients feel comfortable asking questions at every stage.

Here at LongIslandValue.com, Edana and Tom offer that same personal attention to homeowners who want to understand their property’s value and consider their next steps.

Call Edana: 631-816-0719 Our brokerage story →

Thomas BradyLicensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Associate Broker & Director of Operations

Thomas Brady

Tom is Director of Operations at Vintage American Realty, working alongside his daughter, Edana. Before real estate, he served as a Lieutenant with the NYPD and in the U.S. Air Force — two careers built on paying close attention and getting the details right.

He works personally with homeowners across western and central Suffolk County, reviewing property details and comparable sales to help them understand their options. For more about his work with buyers and sellers, including listing terms and town-by-town market notes, visit tombradyhomes.com.

SFR Short Sales & Foreclosure

e-PRO Digital Marketing

SRES Seniors Real Estate

BPOR Broker Price Opinion

C-REPS

NY Notary Public

Call Tom: 631-682-8660

Service Area

Western & Central Suffolk County

If your home is in one of these communities, we focus on the local sales, property characteristics and neighborhood factors that can affect its value.

·Islip

·West Islip

·East Islip

·Bay Shore

·Brightwaters

·Oakdale

·Bohemia

·Sayville

·Patchogue

·Medford

·Ronkonkoma

·Holbrook

·Holtsville

·Farmingville

·Centereach

·Selden

·Lake Grove

·Smithtown

·Hauppauge

·Commack

A boutique brokerage, not a call center.

Led by owner and broker Edana Kiernan, Vintage American Realty is a family-owned boutique brokerage in Oakdale. Edana and her father, Thomas Brady, bring a personal approach to helping you understand your home’s value.

2Local brokers you can speak with

~24hTypical turnaround

Get a range you can actually trust.

Enter your address once. Edana or Tom will review it personally and reply with a price range and the sales it's based on — no auto-generated report, no spam follow-ups.

Request Your Valuation →